The NTSB has determined that the operator
of a small unmanned aircraft system (sUAS)
drone that collided with a U.S. Army helicopter
failed to see and avoid the helicopter because he
was intentionally flying the drone out of visual
range and did not have adequate knowledge of
regulations and safe operating practices.
The incident took place near Hoffman Island,
NY, east of Staten Island, on Sept. 21, 2017,
when a DJI Phantom 4 small unmanned aircraft
system and a U.S. Army Sikorsky UH-60M Black
Hawk helicopter collided at an altitude of about
300 feet. The helicopter landed safely; the drone
was destroyed. A 1-1/2 inch dent was found on
the leading edge of one of the helicopter’s four
main rotor blades and parts of the drone were
found lodged in the helicopter’s engine oil cooler
The drone operator was unaware of the collision
until an NTSB investigator contacted him.
The operator was also not aware of temporary
flight restrictions that were in place at the time
because of President Trump being at his golf
resort in Bedminster, NJ, and a United Nations
General Assembly session taking place.
He was flying the drone recreationally and did
not hold an FAA remote pilot certificate. The
pilot to see and avoid the helicopter due to his
intentional flight beyond visual line of sight.
Contributing to the incident was the small
unmanned aircraft system pilot’s incomplete
knowledge of the regulations and safe operating
The NTSB has released preliminary information
from its investigation of an incident at
Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport,
Atlanta, GA, involving Delta Air Lines flight 2196.
On Nov. 29, 2017, about 1106 eastern standard
time, the Boeing B737-900ER was cleared
to land on, and was initially lined up for, Runway
09R. Radar data indicate that, within about 1 mile
of the runway, flight 2196 began to deviate left of
the approach course and subsequently aligned
with taxiway N. A go-around was initiated after
crossing above the start of the taxiway. The taxiway
was occupied by an airplane at the time, but
flight 2196 did not overfly this airplane during the
go-around. The incident flight was operating
under Part 121 as a scheduled domestic passenger
flight from Indianapolis International Airport,
Indianapolis, Indiana. Daytime instrument meteorological
conditions prevailed at the time of the
The incident first officer was the pilot flying
and the incident captain was the pilot monitoring.
The first officer had accumulated about 3,000
total flight hours with 555 hours in the Boeing
737. The captain has accumulated about 17,000
total flight hours with about 2,200 hours in the
Boeing 737, 1,700 hours of which was as captain.
The flightcrew members reported that the airplane
intercepted the glideslope clear of clouds
but that there was a cloud layer below. The first
officer stated that, about 300 feet AGL and in
IMC, he saw that the airplane was slightly right of
course, so he corrected to the left but overcorrected,
and the airplane deviated left of course.
The first officer reported that, when the airplane
reached the decision height (DH) of 200
feet AGL, the localizer reached full-scale deflection
on the instrument panel. The captain stated
that he called for a go-around at DH because he
did not have the airport environment or approach
lights in sight. Both pilots stated that the captain
called for a go-around before it was called by the
air traffic control (ATC) tower controller.
Both crewmembers stated that they believed
that go-around power may not have been fully set
initially. Both crewmembers reported only exiting
IMC for a brief period during the go-around; they
identified they were to the right of a taxiway at
that time. The flightcrew members of the airplane
on taxiway N stated that they saw the incident airplane
briefly, in and out of the clouds. It did not
overfly them, and they did not recall hearing any
engine noise from the plane.
SUMWALT AT ICAO
NTSB Chairman Robert L. Sumwalt spoke at
the Montreal, Canada, headquarters of the
International Civil Aviation Organization on Dec.
7, 2017. He said, “...the current five-year theme
of ICAO is ‘Working Together to Ensure No
Country is Left Behind.’ Today I met with ICAO
Secretary General Liu and she and I both agree
that we all have an obligation to help each other.
When one of us has information that can help
others, we need to share it.
“...I believe it’s important that the investigation
is independent of outside influences. When the
NTSB was originally formed in 1967, it was
administratively part of the U.S. Department of
Transportation (DOT). In 1974, however,
Congress moved NTSB completely outside of
DOT and made it independent of all other agencies.
“One way to counter misinformation is being
transparent. When I’m talking about transparency,
I’m not talking about tweeting every single thing
that you find. Rather, I’m talking about releasing
factual information, in a controlled and deliberate
manner. I’m talking about allowing the public to
see inside the investigative processes so a reasonable
person can draw the same conclusions
as you did.”
The NTSB is investigating the Dec. 10, 2017,
accident involving a Smith Aerostar 601 which
crashed shortly after taking off from the Miami
Executive Airport (TMB), Miami, FL. The pilot was
fatally injured, and the airplane was destroyed by
impact forces. The airplane was registered to and
operated by the pilot under Part 91 as a personal
flight. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed.
An employee of the flight school where the
airplane was tied down, stated the pilot arrived at
the flight school about 1000 and began to preflight
the airplane. About 1030 he stated that he
needed fuel and he fueled the airplane himself
adding 105.2 gallons of 100LL. It is unknown how
much fuel was put in each of the three fuel tanks.
Shortly thereafter, the pilot taxied the airplane to
the ramp in front of the flight school hangar. The
pilot kept a tool box in the hangar, and the employee stated the pilot was working on the airplane
when he noticed fuel leaking from under
the airplane. The employee stated that the pilot
made a comment that he should have fixed that
before he fueled the airplane. Both the employee
and another witness stated that fuel was leaking
from the aft fuselage belly area. They stated the
pilot had several 5-gallon orange buckets under
the airplane to catch the fuel. Neither witness saw
how much fuel was in the buckets or what the
pilot did with the fuel. The following day it was
noted that there was a 12 foot by 16 foot stain on
the asphalt ramp where the airplane had been
parking. One of the witnesses stated that the
stain was from the fuel that was leaking out of the
A video from a camera at the airport was
reviewed by an FAA Inspector. The video showed
the airplane in front of the hangar at 1135. The
pilot was seen walking back and forth from the
airplane into the hangar where his toolbox was
stored. At 1324, the airplane was pushed back
from the hangar. At 1331, the airplane was started,
and it was taxied out at 1400.
According to air traffic control, the pilot initiated
a takeoff on Runway 31 at 1428. The airplane
became airborne and for some unknown reason,
the pilot aborted the takeoff, landing the airplane
back on the runway. The airplane was taxied
back to the approach end of Runway 31 and a
second takeoff was made. Witnesses in an airplane
waiting to take off on Runway 31 stated
they were second in line to take off behind the
accident airplane. They did not notice anything
unusual until they heard a pilot declare an emergency.
One of the pilots reported the air traffic controller
cleared the pilot to land on any runway,
then cleared him to land on Runway 9R. They
reported the airplane was between 400 feet and
800 feet above the ground and in a left bank,
appearing to be turning back toward Runway 9R.
They stated they thought the pilot was going to
make it back to the runway, but then the left bank
kept increasing past 90 degrees and the nose
The NTSB is investigating the Dec. 10, 2017,
crash of a Textron Aviation (formerly Cessna)
U206G in remote hills in Maunaloa, HI, about 4
miles southwest of the Molokai Airport while performing
an IFR approach. The instrument-rated
private pilot and sole passenger sustained fatal
injuries, and the airplane was destroyed. The
flight originated from the Daniel K. Inouye
International Airport, Honolulu, HI.
While the pilot was conducting a circling
instrument approach, the air traffic controller
observed the airplane south of course at a 6-mile
final and advised the pilot of this status. The pilot
responded that he was correcting, but was
maneuvering to remain clear of clouds. The airplane
then disappeared from the radar display
system and the air control controller transmitted
to the pilot with no response.
The NTSB is investigating the Dec. 9, 2017,
crash of a Beech A36 into a house near
Montgomery-Gibbs Executive Airport (MYF), San
Diego, CA. The pilot and one passenger sustained
serious injuries. Two other passengers
were fatally injured.
The airplane was operated by the pilot as a
Part 91 personal flight. Visual meteorological conditions
prevailed and a VFR flight plan was filed
for the cross-country flight to Los Angeles.
The pilot reported that about 1.5 miles west of
the airport, at 700 feet AGL, the engine experienced
a complete loss of power. He executed a
steep 180 degrees turn to the right and performed
the emergency procedure for loss of
engine power. Engine power was not regained
and he executed a forced landing to a nearby
field. During landing, the pilot applied brakes, but
due to an insufficient stopping distance, the airplane
impacted and traveled through a fence
before colliding with the residence. A post crash
The NTSB is investigating the Dec. 8, 2017,
crash of a Beech C90 into the waters of Lake
Harney, near Geneva, FL. The airplane was operated
as a Part 91 instructional flight. The flight
instructor and two commercial pilots receiving
instruction were fatally injured.
Instrument and visual meteorological conditions
prevailed in the area, and an instrument
flight rules flight plan was filed for the flight, which
originated from Sanford, FL.
Review of preliminary information provided by
the FAA revealed that following an uneventful
flight to Milledgeville, GA, the flight returned to
the Orlando Sanford International Airport (SFB)
and conducted a practice instrument approach to
Runway 09. After the flight completed the instrument
approach, the active runway was changed
to 27R and controllers vectored the flight for a
practice ILS Runway 27R instrument approach.
About 2 minutes after the flight was given a
vector to intercept the localizer and cleared for
the approach, the controller issued a low altitude
alert and advised the flight to climb to 1,600 feet.
Following a second low altitude alert with instructions
to immediately climb to 1,600 feet, the flight
responded that “I am sir, I am.” Shortly after,
radar and radio communication with the accident
airplane were lost.
The NTSB is investigating the Dec. 7, 2017,
crash of a Beech BE58 while it was attempting to
return to the Henry E. Rohlsen Airport (TISX),
Christiansted, St. Croix, United States Virgin
Islands (USVI), shortly after takeoff. The private
pilot and four passengers were fatally injured.
Visual meteorological conditions prevailed, and
no flight plan was filed for the local flight.
The personal flight was conducted under Part
91 and was destined for Cyril E. King Airport
(TIST), Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas, USVI.
According to a preliminary review of air traffic
control audio information, the airplane departed
Runway 10 at TISX. Shortly thereafter, the pilot
reported “the engines are not running right” and
requested to return to the airport. The controller
instructed the pilot to fly north and cleared the airplane
to land on Runway 10. There were no further
communications with the pilot.
The airplane was destroyed by impact forces
and consumed by fire. The wreckage was located
on flat terrain, about 380 feet from the threshold
of Runway 10, about 60 feet right of the extended
The NTSB is investigating the Dec. 6, 2017,
crash of a Raytheon Aircraft Company B36TC airplane into a gas station pump canopy and parking
lot following a reported loss of engine power
while on visual approach to the Spirit of St. Louis
Airport (SUS), Chesterfield, MO. The private pilot
sustained fatal injuries, and the airplane was
destroyed by post impact fire.
The airplane was being operated by a private
individual as a Part 91 personal flight. Day visual
meteorological conditions prevailed and the flight
was conducted on an IFR flight plan. The flight
departed the Phoenix Deer Valley Airport (DVT),
Phoenix, AZ, and was destined for SUS.
According to preliminary radar and communication
information, the airplane was on a left traffic
visual approach to SUS. During the visual
approach, the pilot reported an engine issue and
losing power, and the local controller immediately
cleared the pilot to land on Runway 26L. The pilot
responded that he may not be able to make it to
the airport. No further communications were
received from the pilot.
EXPERIMENTAL SPARROW HAWK
The NTSB is investigating the Dec. 2, 2017,
crash of an experimental amateur-built Sparrow
Hawk gyroplane near Eagles Ridge Airport
(MS9), Hernando, MS. The sport pilot and pilot-
rated passenger were fatally injured. The gyro-
plane was destroyed by a post crash fire. It was
being operated under Part 91 as a local personal
flight. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed.
One person did report having heard a loud
sound similar to a gunshot, but dismissed it.
While walking, he spotted a grass fire. He walked
to a nearby home to tell the homeowner to call
911 to report the fire. First responders who
arrived to extinguish the fire subsequently
observed the wreckage.
The NTSB is investigating the May 5, 2017, crash of a Short Brothers 330 twin-engine turboprop on landing at Yeager Airport, Charleston, WV. The airplane ran off the end of the runway and down a hillside. The pilot and co-pilot were killed. The airplane had been en route from Louisville, KY. It was carrying cargo and was under contract to United Parcel Service. The ceiling was reported to be a 500 foot overcast, but visibility was 10 miles at the time. The accident occurred shortly before 7 a.m.
On April 24, 2017, at 1339 central daylight time, a Bellanca 17-31 airplane collided with high tension power lines and impacted terrain while attempting to land at the Jesse Viertel Memorial Airport (VER), Boonville, Missouri. The pilot and passenger were both fatally injured and the airplane was substantially damaged. The airplane was owned and operated by Select Airplane, LLC, under the provisions of 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91 as a personal flight. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed for the flight that operated without a flight plan.
The airport manager witnessed the accident sequence. He reported that he saw the airplane very low on final approach for runway 18. As the airplane continued towards the airport, he saw it abruptly pitch nose low and descend into the terrain. He immediately contacted emergency service and went to provide aid.
Damage to the power lines were consistent with the airplane colliding with a power line from a set of power lines that were about 75 ft above ground level and about a ½ mile north of the approach end of runway 18. Additional damage to two power lines that were about 15 ft above ground level was found about 110 ft south of the first power line. A subsequent impact crater on the northern shoulder of a 2-lane road, was located about 8 feet south of the second set of struck power lines. The airplane had come to rest inverted on south side of the road, with the nose pointing towards the opposite direction of travel. All major components were located at the accident site.
Visual meteorological conditions prevailed for the accident.
The airplane was retained for further examination.
On April 25, 2017, about 1038 central daylight time, a Cessna model 421C was destroyed when it impacted trees and terrain near Huntsville, Texas. The pilot was fatally injured. The airplane sustained impact and fire damage to all structural components. The aircraft was registered to and operated by Klass Enterprises, LLC, under the provisions of 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91 as a post-maintenance test flight. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed for the flight, which was not on a flight plan. The flight originated from the Lone Star Executive Airport, Conroe, Texas, at an unconfirmed time.
A witness, who was an off-duty police officer, reported seeing the airplane flying in a westerly direction about 150 feet above the ground. He said that the airplane banked left about 45 degrees and he noticed that the left propeller of the airplane was not turning and the airplane was losing altitude. Suspecting a problem, the officer got into his car and in doing so, he heard the operating engine either idle down or shut off completely. The airplane then went out of sight behind a tree line and the officer observed a large plume of smoke. The officer added that when the airplane passed over his residence the flaps appeared to be retracted or at a very low angle and the landing gear was in the retracted position. He noted that the right engine did not did not sound as though it was sputtering or experiencing difficulties until he heard it idle down. He further noted that he did not see any smoke coming from the aircraft as it passed overhead.
The impacted trees and terrain before coming to rest inverted in a shallow ranch pond. The lower portion of the fuselage and the wings remained above the surface of the water and showed evidence of fire damage. Based on the tree impact, the airplane was traveling in a southerly direction when the impact occurred. On-scene examination of the airplane was not possible due to its location in the pond and further examination will be conducted after removal from the accident site.
The NTSB is investigating the April 1, 2017, midair collision of a Cessna 170 and a Grumman American AA5B at Edgewater, FL.
The pilots of both aircraft were killed. It is believed none else was
onboard. There were no fatalities on the ground.
The collision took place about 3 miles north of Massey Airpark at New Smyrna Beach, FL.
Four people were reported killed in the March 25, 2017, crash of a Cessna
210 airplane at Hayden, AL. The airplane had departed Kissimmee, FL, and was en route to Jackson, TN. Witnesses told investigators that
the airplane broke up in flight. NTSB investigators documented that pieces of wreckage were widely separated.
A Cessna Citation jet crashed on March 24, 2017, in Marietta, GA. The airplane was en route to Fulton County Airport at Atlanta from Wilmington, DE. The pilot, who was believed to be the only occupant, was killed. The
airplane crashed into a house. No one was in the structure at the time.
The NTSB is investigating.
A twin-engine Cessna 421 crashed just after midnight on March 4, 2017, at the Cherokee County Regional Airport, Ball Grand, Georgia. The pilot, who was the only occupant, received fatal injuries. The airplane struck wires and a telephone pole before impacting the ground. It is believed that the pilot was attempting to land at the time of the accident.
Two peope were killed in the March 4, 2017, crash of Beechcraft
BE-60 at Duette, Florida, in eastern Manatee County. The airplane
had departed the Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport about
a half-hour before the accident. There was a post crash fire which
affected approximately 30 acres of vegetation and brush.
The pilot who died in the February 28, 2017, crash of a single-engine
Sonex into the roof of a condominium in Methuen, Massachusetts, has been identified as former Newburyport, Massachusetts, Mayor
Alan Lavender, age 73.
The crash site was must across the Merrimack River from Lawrence Airport. The NTSB is investigating. The pilot was on approach for
landing at Lawrence when the accident occurred. It is not believed he made a distress call prior to the accident.
The NTSB is investigating the February 27, 2017, crash of a Cessna 310 into two houses about a half-mile from the Riverside, California, municipal airport. Three people on the airplane were known to have
been killed. One survivor, a teenage girl, was ejected from the airplane and survived with minor injuries. The airplane had taken off from Riverside and was en route to San Jose. Reports said the
airplane's occupants had flown to Riverside for a cheerleading conference.
Two people were killed in the January 5, 2017, crash of a
single-engine Columbia LC41-550FG at Gurdon, AR. The
airplane was en route from McKinney, TX, to Franklin, NC.
The pilot reported engine trouble shortly before the airplane
was observed on radar descending from about FL250 to about 5,000 feet. It then was lost from radar according to preliminary
information. The NTSB is investigating.
The NTSB is investigating the crash of a Cessna 210 at
Phoenix, AZ, on January 2, 2017. All four people onboard
were killed. The airplane was reported missing and
a search was launched early on January 3rd. A cell phone
belonging to one of the occupants was "pinged" and the
signal helped locate the accident scene. The airplane
was en route from Scottsdale, AZ, to Telluride, CO.
A midair collision occurred near Aero County Airport,
McKinney, TX, late in the afternoon of December 31, 2016.
The airport is uncontrolled, and neither pilot was in contact
with Air Traffic Control. The types of aircraft involved could
not immediately be determined. All three people on board both
airplanes were killed. The NTSB is investigating.
Four people have been reported killed in the crash of
a single-engine Piper PA-28 at Vienna, IL. The accident
occurred on December 31, 2016. The NTSB is investigating.
All four people on board a single-engine Cessna were killed
when it crashed December 29, 2016, in the Hood Canal area near
Olympia, WA. The airplane was en route from Boeing Field to Port Angeles, WA. No specifics as to the model of airplane were immediately available. An ELT signal helped search crews locate the crash site. NTSB
investigators were expected to arrive on-scene on Saturday, 12/31/16.
There was no immediate sign of wreckage from the Cessna
Citation 525 jet which was lost from contact with ATC
shortly after takeoff from Burke Lakefront Airport,
Cleveland, OH, at about 11:50 p.m. December 29, 2016.
It is believed the airplane crashed into Lake Erie and
sank about two miles from shore. There were no signs of
survivors. Initial reports indicated there were six people
on board, including family members of one of them who was
the CEO of Superior Beverage Group and owned the airplane
through a corporation. The airplane was based at Ohio State University Airport in Columbus, OH, and was en route there. The NTSB will
The wreckage of a Cessna 182H which was reported missing
December 26, 2016, on a flight from Jacksonville, FL, to
Gatlinburg-Pigeon Forge Airport on Tennessee has been
discovered. the plane crashed in remote terrain in the
Great Smoky Mountains National Park. All three people
on the airplane were killed. The NTSB is investigating.
Two people were killed December 27, 2016, in the crash of an Epic LT at Spruce Creek Airport, Port Orange, FL. The LT is a high-performance single-engine turboprop with six seats. It is a low-wing design, with retractable gear. The airplane was en route from Millington Regional Airport in Tennessee. The NTSB is investigating.
The NTSB is investigating the Nov. 18, 2016, crash of a twin-engine
PA-31 at Elko, NV, in which all four onboard were killed. The airplane was being operated by American Medflight as an air ambulance flight.
The airplane carried the pilot, two medical personnel and a
The National Transportation Safety Board issued a Safety Alert to pilots with suggestions on what they can do to reduce their chances of being involved in a midair collision.
In an effort to illustrate the limitations of the “see and avoid” concept of aircraft separation, the NTSB created a series of animations depicting the pilots’ visual field of view from each of the four airplanes involved in two midair collisions that were investigated by the NTSB in 2015.
The animations show how difficult it can be for pilots to spot converging aircraft that may present a midair collision risk in a dynamic visual environment.
Using 3-D laser equipment, investigators scanned the cockpit windows and surrounding airplane structure of four exemplar airplanes involved in the two midair collisions to create animations that, combined with radar data, provided an approximation of what each pilot likely saw before the crashes. Investigators also used radar data to reconstruct how in-cockpit technology that provides pilots with graphical and aural alerts of nearby traffic could have made the pilots aware of the approaching aircraft and possibly prevented the collisions.
“These accidents and the animations clearly demonstrate the safety benefit of augmenting pilots’ vision with technological safety nets,” said NTSB Chairman Christopher A. Hart. “Technologies in the cockpit that warn of traffic conflicts through displays or alerts can help pilots become aware of, and maintain separation from, nearby aircraft, even if they have difficulty seeing them.”
On July 7, 2015, a Cessna 150 that had just departed from Moncks Corner, South Carolina, and an F-16 Air Force fighter jet on a training mission collided. An air traffic controller advised the F-16 pilot that the Cessna was a potential traffic conflict. The F-16 pilot was not able to visually acquire the Cessna until it was too late to avoid the collision. The two occupants of the Cessna were killed; the F-16 pilot ejected and survived. The NTSB determined that the probable cause of the crash was the air traffic controller’s failure to provide an appropriate resolution to the traffic conflict.
On August 16, 2015, a North American Rockwell Sabreliner inbound for landing at Brown Field Municipal Airport in San Diego and a Cessna 172 that was practicing landings at the same airport collided. The four occupants of the Sabreliner and the sole occupant of the Cessna were killed. A cockpit visibility study revealed the fields of view of both pilots were limited and partially obscured at times. The NTSB determined that the probable cause of the accident was the air traffic controller’s failure to properly identify the aircraft in the pattern and to ensure control instructions were being performed.
The NTSB said that contributing to both accidents were the inherent limitations of the “see and avoid” concept of traffic separation. These limitations, combined with errors by the air traffic controllers, resulted in the pilots’ inability to take action to avoid the collisions.
The Safety Alert highlights the value of traffic avoidance technologies to pilots as an aid to detecting and avoiding other airplanes in flight. Such technologies also serve as another layer of safety in the case of air traffic control errors, such as those referenced in the two accidents above.
In addition to issuing the Safety Alert, the NTSB made recommendations to the Federal Aviation Administration and the three companies operating federal contract control towers in the U.S., asking them to brief air traffic controllers on the errors in the two midair collisions and to include these accidents as examples in initial and recurrent training.
As part of its ongoing investigation of an Oct. 28, 2016, uncontained engine failure on American Airlines flight 383, the National Transportation Safety Board issued an investigative update Friday, Nov. 14, 2016.
The uncontained failure of a GE CF6-80C2B6 engine occurred on a Boeing 767-300 (N345AN) during the take-off roll at Chicago O'Hare International Airport. An emergency evacuation of the 161 passengers and nine crewmembers onboard was conducted.
Initial findings include the following:
According to witness statements from airport personnel, video evidence, flight data recorder (FDR) data and GPS data, the accident flight started its takeoff roll on runway 28R at the intersection with taxiway N5.
The airplane experienced an uncontained failure of the right engine about 6,550 feet from runway 28R threshold, and came to a full stop about 9,225 feet from runway 28R threshold.
Preliminary FDR data show that the right engine failure
occurred at an airspeed of about 128 knots with the engine
operating at takeoff power.
Approximately two seconds after the engine failure, at an
airspeed of about 134 knots, the left and right engine throttle
lever angles decreased rapidly. Coincident with the throttle
movement, brake pressure rose in a manner consistent with maximum
autobrake application; the auto speedbrakes were extended.
The aircraft rapidly decelerated, coming to a stop about 25 seconds
after the throttle reduction.
As a result of the uncontained engine failure, a fuel leak resulted in a
pool fire under the right wing.
Airport Rescue and Fire Fighting personnel began applying foam within
2 minutes 51 seconds of being notified of the emergency.
The right engine stage 2 high pressure turbine disk fractured into at
least 4 pieces (locations A, B, C, and D on figure). One piece went through
the inboard section of the right wing, over the fuselage and into
a UPS warehouse facility (location A).
The majority of the stage 2 disk was recovered and sent to the NTSB
laboratory in Washington, DC for examination. One of the fractures exhibited features
consistent with fatigue cracking initiating at an internal inclusion near the forward
side of the hub’s inner bore.
Engine and wing debris were found in the area around the gouge mark on the runway.
3-D imaging of the damage to the right wing has been completed.
All members of the cabin crew has been interviewed.
The disk had 10,984 cycles and had a life limit of 15,000 cycles. Review of the
engine maintenance and manufacturing records and processes are ongoing.
Daily progress meetings are being held and the final documentation and examination
of the airplane and engine continues in Chicago; the on-scene team plans to finish
work by this weekend.
NTSB Senior Air Safety Investigator Lorenda Ward, the Investigator-in-Charge, is
leading a team with expertise in the areas of airworthiness, powerplants, structures,
survival factors, maintenance records, flight recorders and metallurgy. The flight data
recorder and the cockpit voice recorder were transported to the NTSB Recorder Laboratory
where the information from each was downloaded.
Parties to the investigation include the Federal Aviation Administration,
American Airlines, Allied Pilots Association, The Boeing Company, General Electric Engines,
the Transport Workers Union of America and the Association of Professional Flight Attendants.
Ongoing metallurgical examinations of the disk will focus on detailed characterization of
the inclusion and the fracture surfaces.
The NTSB is investigating the October 16, 2016, crash of a
Piper Cherokee near Austin, PA, in which all three people on
board were killed. The airplane was en route to St. Catherine's/
Niagara District Airport, Ontario, Canada, from Richmond, VA.
At about 7pm, the pilot advised ATC that they were maneuvering
to avoid a thunderstorm. The wreckage was found the following
day in mountainous terrain.
The NTSB has adopted a probable cause of the Nov. 10, 2015, crash
of a Hawker HS-125 jet into an apartment building in Akron, OH. All
nine people on the airplane were killed. There were no fatalities
on the ground. The Safety Board blamed the accident on the
unstabilized non-precision approach which was flown and the captain's
failure to call for or execute a go-around. The first officer was the flying
pilot. The Safety Board also found fault with the FAA's oversight of
the flight's operator, ExecuFlight, as well as the company's failure
to provide adequate training to its pilots.
NTSB investigators were expected to arrive Wednesday at the crash site
in East Hartford, CT, where a PA-34 twin-engine Seneca crashed while on approach
to Hartford-Brainard Airport on Tuesday 10/11/16. The pilot survived, while the
pilot-rated passenger was killed. The FBI has joined the investigation,
following an indication from the pilot that the crash was not an accident. It
was subsequently determined that the pilot-rated passenger was intent
upon committing suicide. The pilot-rated passenger was identified as
Feras M. Freitkh, who was said to be of Jordanian background.
His private pilot certificate was valid for single-engine land aircraft. The
airplane was registered to a flight school. The crash site was near a
Pratt & Whitney plant. P&W manufactures aircraft engines. Two people
in a vehicle received minor injuries.
One person was killed and one was injured in the crash
October 4, 2016, of a twin-engine Beech D95A at Hitchcock, TX,
about 17 miles west of Galveston. The survivor called 911
to alert authorities to the crash and ask for help.
Three people have been killed in the crash of a Cessna 208B
near Togiak, AK. The airplane went down in mountainous
terrain, about 200 miles northwest of Anchorage. The airplane
was en route from Togiak to Quinhagak, which would have
been a flight of about 70 miles.
Two people were killed and a third received serious
injuries in the September 25, 2016, crash of a Mooney M20J
in Hunterdon County, NJ. The single-engine airplane was
on approach to Sky Manor Airport. It struck trees and crashed
in a residential yard. A witness reportedly said the airplane had
touched down at the airport, but was traveling too fast
and getting to close to the end of the runway, so the pilot
executed a go-around. The witness reportedly said the airplane
barely cleared trees, then entered a turn and descended.
Three people were killed on September 25, 2016, in the
mid-air collision of a Piper Cherokee (exact model not
immediately reported) and a single-engine Cessna (exact
model not immediately reported) at North Collins, NY.
Both aircraft departed Hamburg Airport en route to
St. Mary's, PA, for a fly-in breakfast. The aircraft
which collided were part of a group of six aircraft
en route to St. Mary's.
All three people on board a twin-engine Beech B-55
were killed when it crashed at Broudus, MT, on September
17, 2016. The airplane was en route from Billings, MT,
to Rapid City, IA.
Two people were killed in the crash of a Piper PA-28-235
at Lee's Summit Municipal Airport in Missouri, on September 20, 2016.
The airplane was en route from Des Moines, IA, to Lee's Summit.
It had touched down, but the pilot apparently then entered a go-around.
The NTSB is investigating.
One crewmember survived, but the other was killed after
ejecting from a U-2 just before it crashed at Sutter Buttes,
about 60 miles north of Sacramento, California, on
September 20, 2016. the U-2 had taken off from Beale
Air force Base on a training mission.
A Cessna 182 crashed into a house in Gilbert, AZ, on
September 17, 2016. The two people in the house escaped
injury. The airplane had been on a night/VFR skydiving
flight. An in-flight fire had broken out, and the
pilot and four skydivers onboard parachuted to safety.
The NTSB is investigating.
The NTSB is investigating the September 14, 2016,
crash of a PA-11 at Arcanum, OH. Both people on board
were killed. The airplane crashed in a corn field The
airplane was reported to have been en route to
West Carrollton, OH.
All three people on board a Piper Cherokee, specific model not
reported, were killed when the airplane crashed into a parking
lot at the Reno-Tahoe International Airport in California. The
airplane had just taken off. It was reported that the airplane
was destined for San Carlos, CA. The accident occurred
on September 11, 2016. The NTSB is ivnestigating.
Three people were killed in the September 7, 2016, mid-air
collision of a Diamond DA-20 and a Beech F33A at the
West Georgia Regional Airport, Carrolton, GA. The airport
is uncontrolled. Both airplanes reportedly were in the
pattern for landing. The NTSB is investigating.
Three fatal accidents on 9/3/16 being investigated by
the NTSB: 1 dead in gyrocopter crash at Bryant, AR,
a suburb of Little Rock; 2 killed in the crash of a
Cessna (model not identified) at Liberty, TX;
two killed in crash of Cessna C-172 en route from
Pompano Beach to Key Largo in the water
about 4 miles south of Port Everglades, FL.
Five people are reported to have been killed in
the mid-air collision of two airplanes about 60
milers north of Bethel, AK, on August 31, 2016.
The airplanes were a Cessna C-208 and a
Piper PA-18 Super Cub. The collision took
place about 6 miles from Russian Mission,
Alaska. The NTSB is investigating.
A 1981 Beech Bonanza crashed while on approach
to the Reno-Tahoe International Airport, Sparks, NV.
The airplane came down in an RV park, and set
several cars and RV's on fire. The pilot of the airplane
was killed. The accident took place on August 30, 2016.
The NTSB is investigating.
A 1983 Beech Bonanza crashed while taking off from the
Bentonville Municipal Airport in Arkansas on
August 31, 2016. The pilot was killed. The airplane struck
a hangar. The NTSB is investigating.
ICE ROAD TRUCKERS
Darrell Ward, a participant in the television reality series
"Ice Road Truckers," carried by The History Channel, was
killed in the crash of a Cessna 182 on August 28, 2016, near
Missoula, MT. Also killed was the pilot/owner of the
aircraft. The NTSB is investigating.
The NTSB is investigating the August 27, 2016, crash of a
Boeing PT17 Stearman during the Air Show of the Cascades
at Madras, OR. The pilot, aerobatics performer Marcus Paine,
was killed. Witnesses said the airplane was in a low altitude
loop, with its smoke trail functioning, when it struck the
The model of Cessna which crashed into Lake Pontchartrain
at about 8:15 p.m., on August 27, 2016, was not immediately
identified, Two men on board the airplane were missing, while
a woman was rescued. The airplane was on approach to
Lakefront Airport at New Orleans at the time of the accident,
and had been on a local sightseeing flight. The NTSB is
Six people were killed in the August 14, 2016, crash of a
Piper PA-31 at the Tuscaloosa Regional Airport, Tuscaloosa, AL.
The NTSB is investigating. The airplane was en route from
Kissimmee, FL, to Oxford, MS. The pilot reported engine
problems and was attempting to make a precautionary
landing at Tuscaloosa.
The NTSB is investigating the crash of a Beech 95-B55
on August 12, 2016, in the vicinity of the Shannon Airport in
Spotsylvania County, VA. Six people were killed. The airplane
touched down about midway along the runway then started a
go-around. The airplane climbed and entered a turn, then likely
The pilot, who was the only occupant, was killed in the
August 13, 2016, crash of a Citabria at Birchwood Airport,
Chugiak, AK. The airplane had just departed runway
2R. The NTSB is investigating.
The type of light sport aircraft which crashed August 2, 2016,
near the Van Nuys Airport in California was not immediately
identified. The pilot was killed in the accident. The airplane
struck an industrial building. The pilot had been doing touch
and goes at the airport.
The NTSB is investigating the August 1, 2016, crash of a
Lancair 360 homebuilt airplane at Columbia Gorge
Regional Airport, Dallesport, OR. The pilot was killed when
the airplane crashed onto a taxiway at the airport at
All 16 people on board were killed in a hot air balloon accident
at Lockhart, TX, on July 30, 2016. The NTSB is investigating.
Initial reports indicated that a fire broke out while the balloon
was airborne, and it descended into power lines. The accident
took place at approximately 7:40 am, local time.
Reach Air Medical Services says the Piper PA-31 Cheyenne II
which crashed July 29, 2016, in Humboldt County, California,
carried the pilot, two medical personnel and a patient.
However, as of Friday afternoon, only two bodies had been
located. The airplane was on a night flight from Crescent
City to Oakland, California. The pilot declared an emergency
due to smoke in the cockpit and stated that he was returning
to Crescent City. The NTSB is investigating.
Four people were killed in the crash of a Cessna 310 near
the Columbia Airport, Columbia, CA, on July 27, 2016.
The airplane was on approach for landing at the time.
A post crash fire erupted. The NTSB is investigating.
The NTSB is investigating the July 25, 2016, crash of a Beech
Baron at Leshara, Nebraska. Both people on board were killed.
One was identified as a serviceman assigned to Offutt Air Force
Base. The other was identified as a civilian flight instructor.
The airplane was registered to the successor organization to
the Offutt Aero Club.
The people who were killed in the July 22, 2016, crash of a
homebuilt RV-9A in Harmony Township, Ohio, about 40 miles
east of Dayton, have been identified as the former Mayor of
Allen Park, Ohio, Levon King, and his wife. The NTSB is
investigating the accident, It is reported there was rain in
the area, with occasional thunderstorms.
The NTSB is investigating the July 23, 2016, mid-air collision of
two Air Tractor cropdusters near Knights Landing in Yolo County,
California. The pilot of one of the airplanes was killed, while the
pilot of the other escaped with minor injuries.
The NTSB has started investigating the July 21, 2016, crash of a
Piper PA-30 Twin Comanche in a residential neighborhood of Plainfield, IL, south
of Chicago. The pilot, who is believed to have been the only person
on board, was killed. A house was set on fire as a result of the crash
and post crash fire. It is believed the airplane began its journey in
Florida, stopped in Tennessee and was en route to Wisconsin.
The NTSB is investigating the July 18, 2016, crash of a single-engine
Aeronca 11AC at Ely Township, MI. Both occupants were killed.
A single-engine Diamond DA-40 crashed on July 18, 2016, at Hyrum, UT.
The student pilot, who was the only occupant, was killed. The airplane
had taken off from the Logan-Cache Airport in Utah. The student was attending
Utah state University's aviation program. the NTSB is investigating.
Three people were killed and a fourth seriously injured in the crash of
a single-engine Piper PA-28 at Esperance, NY, on July 16, 2016. The aircraft
model was not immediately identified, beyond being a four-seat Piper PA-28.
The airplane was taking off from Hogan Airport in Esperance at about 6:45 p.m.
It crashed about 1,000 feet beyond the departure end of the runway.
Esperance is located in Schoharie County in upstate New York. The
NTSB is investigating.
The NTSB is investigating the July 8, 2016, crash of a six-seat single-engine
Piper PA-32 near the West Houston Airport, Houston, TX. All 4 people on board
were killed. There was a post crash fire. The airplane had just taken off
from the airport.
Two test pilots were killed in the crash of a prototype Bell 525 helicopter which
had been undergoing flight testing. The twin-engine helicopter went down at
Chamber Creek, TX, on July 6, 2016. The new model is expected to receive
approval to enter commercial service sometime next year. The helicopter
which crashed had been undergoing testing for about a year. The NTSB is
investigating. Bell Helicopter has two other 525's which also have been in
the test program.
VANS RV7 FOUND
Wreckage of the Vans RV7 which was reported missing on July 3, 2016,
was found on July 4, 2016, by the Civil Air Patrol near Florida City, FL.
The pilot, who was the only occupant, was killed. The airplane had
departed from the airport at Boca Raton, FL. The NTSB will be
A single-engine airplane, type not yet reported, crashed at
Buena Vista, CO, July 4, 2016, killing the pilot.
The NTSB is investigating the July 3, 2016, crash of a Piper PA-22
airplane at Frankenmuth, MI, in which both occupants were killed.
The airplane went down in a field. It was reported to have been based
at Zehnder field in Frankenmuth.
Senator Jim Inhofe, Republican of Oklahoma, escaped serious injury on
Saturday, July 3, 2016, when the single-engine airplane he was flying
ran off a runway at South Grand Lake Regional Airport, Ketchum, OK.
There was an initial report that Inhofe had to maneuver to avoid hitting
a deer on the runway. It also was suggested that a gust of wind may have
caused Inhofe to lose control. Inhofe was reported to have been forced to
make a precautionary landing in the Harmon Rocket because of adverse
weather which had moved into the area.
PRELIMINARY REPORT P-47D
On May 27, 2016, about 1930 eastern daylight time, a Republic P-47D, N1345B,
ditched in the Hudson River following a reported loss of engine power. The
commercial pilot was fatally injured and the airplane was substantially damaged.
The experimental, exhibition-category airplane was registered to a corporation
and was operated by the American Airpower Museum under the provisions of Title
14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91 as an aerial observation flight. Day, visual
meteorological conditions prevailed at the time of the accident, and no flight plan
was filed. The local flight originated from Republic Airport (FRG), Farmingdale, New York, about 1900.
The accident aircraft was part of a three-ship formation and the pilot was
participating in a photo shoot. During the flight, the pilot made a distress call
to Newark air traffic control tower and subsequently ditched the airplane in the
Hudson River, south of the George Washington Bridge.
The airplane impacted the water and sank. Attempts by first responders
to rescue the pilot were unsuccessful. The wreckage was recovered from the river
the following day and was transported to the West 30th Street Heliport, New York, New York.
An initial examination of the wreckage revealed that the airframe was generally intact.
The engine remained attached to the airframe. A cursory examination of the engine revealed
that the number 18 cylinder on the Pratt and Whitney R-2800 radial engine was damaged,
consistent with an in-flight occurrence. Oil was present on the exterior of the engine.
The airframe and engine were retained for further examination.
The pilot held a commercial pilot certificate with airplane single engine land,
airplane multi-engine land, airplane single engine sea, rotorcraft-helicopter,
and instrument airplane ratings. He also held a Federal Aviation Administration
(FAA) airframe and powerplant mechanic certificate. The pilot held a FAA second
class medical certificate and reported 6,400 total hours of flying experience on
his medical certificate application that was dated August 5, 2015.
The NTSB is investigating the June 19, 2016, crash of a twin-engine
Piper PA-23 in Hayward, California. The airplane crashed on tracks
used by the BART, Bay Area Rapid Transit, causing service to be
disrupted. The pilot was killed in the crash. A post crash fire erupted.
Two people have been killed in the crash of a Piper PA-31
Thursday (6/16/16) about one mile east of University Airpark,
State College, Pennsylvania. The aircraft was registered to
an air ambulance service. Controllers in the tower observed
smoke coming from the airplane as it was on approach to
the airport. The NTSB is investigating.
Three people were killed in the crash on June 15, 2016, of
a Cessna 320 registered to an aerial survey company. The crash
was about one-half mile from the Central Colorado Regional
Airport, Buena Vista, Colorado. The airplane had flown to the
airport from Longmont, Colorado. It was on a mission to take
aerial photographs. The NTSB is investigating.
There are reports that the pilot of the Mooney which crashed
Saturday (6/11/16) near the Collegedale Municipal Airport in
Tennessee told air traffic control that oil was accumulating on the
windshield of the single-engine airplane. Two people were killed
and two injured in the accident. It was reported that the airplane
had been en route to Chattanooga, TN, but diverted to
Collegedale when the trouble started because it was which was
the closest airport. The NTSB is investigating.
The NTSB is investigating the June 9, 2016, crash of a
PZL-Mielec M-18 Dromader cropduster in Brunswick County,
NC. The pilot, who was the only occupant, was killed.
Investigators reportedly have learned that the airplane took off
with about 45-minutes of fuel on board. The M-18 single-engine
airplane is built in Poland.
The NTSB is investigating the June 10, 2016, crash of a
Grumman American AA-1B into a townhouse building
at Hawthorne, CA. Two people on board the single-engine
airplane were killed. A fire damaged much of the townhouse.
The accident location was about one mile from the
Hawthorne Municipal Airport.
Three people were killed in the June 9, 2016, crash of
a Piper PA-28-140 Cherokee into a lake about one mile
from Wishek Airport, Wishek, ND. It is believed that
the airplane had just taken off from the airport when it
went down in May Lake. The airport is uncontrolled and
investigators were attempting to locate witnesses.
The NTSB will be investigating today's (6/9/16) crash
of a single-engine Cirrus SR20 in a parking lot near
Houston Hobby Airport, Houston, TX. Three people were
killed, all believed to have been aboard the airplane.
The airplane struck a car, believed to have been empty,
outside of an Ace Hardware store.
Both military and civilian investigators will look into the
June 2, 2016, crash of a Navy F/A-18 Hornet jet on June 2, 2016,
at Smyrna, GA. The airplane was being operated as part of the
Navy's Blue Angels aerial performance group. The pilot was
killed in the accident. The Blue Angels were practicing for
their appearance in this weekend's Great Tennessee Airshow
at the Smyrna/Rutherford County Airport.
The NTSB is investigating the June 1, 2016, crash of a Cessna 150K
in Ector County, TX. The airplane was being operated by an aerial
patrol company. at about 11 pm local time, it struck a concrete
silo. The pilot was killed.
The NTSB is investigating the May 28, 2016, crash of
single-engine VariEze homebuilt aircraft in a lemon orchard
between Ventura and Santa Paula, CA. Both people on board
were killed. The two-seat canard airplane was involved in a
post crash fire.
The NTSB is investigating the May 27, 2016, crash of a
World War II airplane into New York City's Hudson River.
The P-47 Thunderbolt had departed Republic Airport in
Farmingdale, NY. It was scheduled to perform in a
Memorial Day airshow at Jones Beach. Witnesses reported
seeing smoke trailing from the engine area while it was
descending to the water. The pilot made an emergency
radio call on the emergency frequency, 121.5. which was heard
by FAA air traffic control. Witness said the airplane sank
quickly, and they could see the pilot, who was the only occupant,
struggling to open the canopy. Divers recovered a body from
LIGHT SPORT KP-5
Both occupants were killed in the May 24, 2016, crash of a
Sihlavan KP-5 light sport aircraft near Rhoadsville, VA. The
flight originated at the Orange County Airport in Virginia.
The KP-5 is a low wing, two seat light sport aircraft with a
tilt-up canopy. The NTSB is investigating the accident.
The NTSB is investigating the May 23, 2016, crash of a Cessna 182H
near Hanapepe on the island of Kauai, HI, in which all 5 people on
board were killed. The airplane was being used for a skydiving flight.
It carried a pilot, two instructors, and two individuals who were planning
to make tandem jumps with the instructors. The airplane had taken off
from the Port Allen Airport. A post crash fire broke out.
The NTSB is investigating the May 17, 2016, crash of a North American
AT-6 at Mesa, AZ, in which both occupants were killed. There was a
post crash fire. The airplane had taken off from Falcon Field at
Mesa shortly before it went down on a road at the airport's perimeter.
It was believed that the airplane World War II vintage aircraft was
built in 1942.
All four people aboard were killed May 16, 2016, when a Beech B36 Bonanza
crashed shortly after taking off from the Tupelo Municipal Airport in
Mississippi. An FAA report indicates that the pilot reported smoke
in the cockpit shortly before the crash. The airplane had flown to
Tupelo from Kerrville, TX, on Sunday. It was en route on Monday from
Tupelo to Charlottesville, VA. The NTSB will be investigating.
The pilot apparently was the only occupant of a Cessna 182 which
crashed on May 15, 2016, in the Angeles National Forest, north
of Altadena, CA. He was killed. The airplane was en route from
San Diego to Santa Monica Municipal Airport in California. Contact
with ATC was lost about 17 miles east of Van Nuys, CA. The crash
site was near Brown Mountain in the national forest.
The NTSB is investigating the May 14, 2016, crash of a Pitts
biplane being used in an air show at the Peachtree-DeKalb Airport,
Chamblee, GA. The pilot was killed when the airplane crashed and
burned during an aerobatic display.
The NTSB is investigating the May 7, 2016, crash of a Beech G35
single-engine airplane in a gated community in Surprise, AZ.
The pilot was killed and a passenger received serious injuries.
Surprise is near Phoenix.
The pilot of a 1961 Piper PA-28 executed an emergency landing to
the roof of a building in Pomona, CA, on May 8, 2016. He was the
only occupant of the airplane, and received serious injuries. He reported
that the Lycoming O-320 engine lost power. The airplane was en route
from Fullerton, CA, to Pomona in day/VFR conditions.
The NTSB is investigating the May 3, 2016, crash of a Beech B-35
at Syosset, NY, in which all three occupants were killed. The airplane
apparently broke up in-flight. The pilot had declared an emergency with
ATC, stating that he was "losing the panel." The flight originated from
Myrtle Beach, SC, and was en route to Robertson Field, Plainville,
CT. The debris field stretched for about two miles.
The pilot was killed and the two passengers were hospitalized in
critical condition when the six-seat single-engine Piper PA-32 they
were on crashed on the Boone Golf Course at Boone, NC. The
accident took place at about 1pm on April 25, 2016. The airplane had
just taken off from the Boone Airport. The NTSB is in charge of the
The NTSB will be investigating the April 25, 2016, crash of a single-engine
Beech 76 in a residential neighborhood of Pompano Beach, FL. The airplane
was being used to practice touch and go landings at the Pompano Beach
Airport. It was registered to the Florida Aviation Academy. The airplane
wreckage hit several houses, setting fire to at least one. The three occupants
of the airplane was removed in critical condition.
An NTSB investigator was dispatched to the scene of the April 20, 2016,
crash of a Cessna 172 single-engine airplane at Chugiak, AK. Four people
were aboard the airplane; all were killed in the crash and post crash fire.
Chugiak is about 20 miles northeast of Anchorage, AK.
A Beech 65 being used for mosquito control spraying crashed while returning
to land at the airport in Slidell, LA. The airplane was one of two on the night
mission. The accident took place at about 9:30 p.m., on April 19, 2016. Both
people on the B-65 were killed. The airplane struck power lines and a tree. A
post crash fire erupted.
The NTSB will be involved in investigating the April 19, 2016, crash of a Van's RV-12
single-engine aircraft short of runway 29 at the Bay Bridge Airport, Kent Island, MD.
Both occupants were killed. A post crash fire consumed much of the aircraft. The
Chesapeake Sport Pilot group said an aircraft "associated" with it had been involved
in an accident and the group would be cooperating with investigators in trying to
determine what caused the crash.
The NTSB planned to send investigators from its Seattle, WA, and Anchorage, AK, offices to Admiralty
Island, south of Juneau, AK, where a Cessna 206 airplane crashed on April 8, 2016, killing three of
the people on board, including the pilot. One passenger survived and was taken to a hospital in
Juneau for treatment. He was subsequently flown to a medical center in Seattle, WA. The airplane
had been en route from Wrangell, AK, to Angoon on Admiralty Island. The airplane crashed at an
elevation of about 2,300 feet in mountainous terrain on the southeast end of the island. The airplane's
ELT activated. The Coast Guard launched a search and a commercial helicopter changed course to
help investigate. The commercial helicopter located the wreckage. A Coast Guard helicopter lowered
rescuers to the crash site since terrain conditions prevented landing. The airplane was registered to
Sunrise Aviation, a Part 135 charter operator in Wrangell, AK.
The NTSB is investigating the April 4, 2016, crash of a Bell 206 helicopter being used for sightseeing
near Great Smoky Mountains National Park at Sevierville, TN. All five people on board
were killed in the crash and post impact fire. The crash site was at the foot of a mountain, about
a mile from a shopping mall and three miles from the Dollywood Theme Park founded by
singer/actress Dolly Parton. Much of the helicopter was consumed by the fire.
The NTSB is investigating the April 2, 2016, crash of a Lancair IV kit-built airplane on Interstate 15
near Fallbrook, CA. The airplane struck a car that was stopped alongside the road. A woman in
the car was killed, and the driver and two passengers received serious injuries. The pilot of the
airplane and his passenger received serious injuries. A witnesses told the California Highway
Patrol that he did not hear any sound from the airplane's engine as it descended. The airplane
slid about 250 feet after touching down before it struck the car.
The NTSB is investigating the March 26, 2016, accident involving a Cessna 172 Skyhawk at Yeager
airport, Charleston, West Virginia. The flight instructor was killed, and the student received serious
injuries. The airplane was taking off from runway 05 when it flipped over and caught fire. The
accident took place at about 12:15 p.m. The fire was extinguished, and the two people on board
were removed and transported to a hospital, where the flight instructor died.
There was low visibility in fog at the time a Eurocopter AS350 medical helicopter crashed
March 26, 2016, after responding to a single-car accident near Goodman, Alabama. An NTSB
spokesman says the crash site is wooded and swampy, and equipment was being brought in to
move the helicopter after an initial of the accident site. The pilot, a nurse, a medic, and the patient
on board all were killed.
The helicopter's operator, Metro Aviation, operates about 130 helicopters based in 18 states. The
helicopter had responded to the automobile accident at about 11 p.m., Saturday night. It was
reported missing early Sunday morning. The wreckage was discovered about 7:00 a.m., Sunday
morning about one-half mile from the scene of the car wreck.
The NTSB, along with investigators from the FAA and Boeing, will take part in the investigation
into the March 19, 2016, crash of a Flydubai Boeing 737-800 in the Rostov region of southwest Russia.
All 62 people on board Flight 981 from Dubai were killed. There were seven crewmembers and
It is believed the airplane was starting its second missed approach when the
crash occurred. The crash site was 800 feet short of the runway at Rostov-on-Don Airport,
which could be consistent with a missed approach procedure having begun. The accident
occurred at about 3:50 a.m., local time according to Russian officials. They said weather
at the time included wind gusts to 60 mph and reduced visibility. They said the airplane had
been holding for about two hours waiting for improved weather conditions. The Cockpit Voice
Recorder and Digital Flight Data Recorder have been recovered.
The U.S. representatives were invited to participate in the investigation because the airplane's
manufacturer, Boeing, is a U.S. company.
Two people are reported to have been killed in the March 18, 2016, crash of a Cessna 340
twin-engine airplane at Peter O. Knight Airport, Tampa, FL. The accident occurred at
about 11:45 a.m. The airplane was destroyed in the crash and a post crash fire. The
airplane was en route to Pensacola, FL. The airport is located a couple of miles south of
downtown Tampa. The NTSB will be investigating along with the FAA.
The NTSB is investigating the March 13, 2016, crash of a Cessna 182A about a mile north of the
airport in Alpine, Wyoming. The accident site is near the Idaho-Wyoming border. All four people
on board were killed. A post crash fire consumed most of the airplane. The 182A was built in
1958 according to the FAA Aircraft Registry.
It took a couple of days
for investigators to
identify the airplane
which crashed and two
who were killed on March
2, 2016, at Palmer Lake,
Colorado. Very little
remained of the airplane
to an intense post crash
fire. The NTSB is
investigating the crash
which involved a Curtiss
TravelAir 4000, which
dated from about 1928.
The pilot was identified
as Daniel Murray of
Longmont, Colorado, who
was the owner of the
airplane. The passenger
was identified as Jeff
of Lafayette, Colorado.
The airplane was based
at Vance Brand Municipal
Airport. The passenger
was reported to also
have owned vintage
The NTSB is
investigating the March
1, 2016, crash of an
experimental Vans RV-6
at Elmdale Airpark,
The crash occurred about
8:50 a.m. Both people
on board the
were killed. Witnesses
said the airplane
stall during takeoff and
hit terrain on the north
end of the runway.
The NTSB is
investigating the crash
Sunday morning, February
28, 2016, of a Cirrus
near the Navasota
Municipal Airport in
Texas in which two
adults and two children
indicates that the
took off from David
Hooks Airport in Houston
about 8:17 a.m. The
crash site was about 34
southeast of Hooks
Airport. The wreckage
was spotted at about
9:17 a.m. by a pilot
who was flying over
wooded terrain about
one-half mile southeast
of the Navasota
airport. It was reported
that the airplane is
registered to a company
On Friday, February 26,
2016, the NTSB adopted a
probable cause of the
November 29, 2013
crash of a Cessna 206B
operated as a Part 135
passenger flight at St.
Four people were killed
and six seriously
minutes late for
the first leg of
at the first
diverted to the
and received a
an air route
and proceeded in
a direct line to
that his audio
selected to the
to activate the
lighting at the
on the ARTCC
witnesses on the
ground at St.
that the airport
they saw the
over, and then
Witnesses in the
the weather at
the airport as
with fog and
ice. About 1
mile from the
followed by a
right turn and
to be in control
of the airplane
up to the point
of the right
Given the lack
to fog, and the
awareness of the
led to his
A review of FAA
that they opened
action had been
FAA did not hold
evident in this
comply with its
The NTSB determined that
the probable cause of
this accident was the
pilot's decision to
a visual flight rules
approach into an area of
conditions at night and
release of the flight
without discussing the
risks with the pilot,
in the pilot
experiencing a loss of
controlled flight into
terrain. Contributing to
the accident were the
control and flight
release and its
inadequate training and
oversight of operational
Also contributing to the
accident was the FAA's
failure to hold the
operator accountable for
ensuring compliance with
its operational control
The NTSB has
interviewed the pilot of
the Bell 206B helicopter
which was damaged when
impacted water during an
emergency landing near
Honolulu, HI, on
February 18, 2016. Video
of the helicopter
impacting the water was
widely seen. The
registered to a
private individual and
operated by Genesis
Helicopters under Part
91 as a local air tour
The commercial pilot and
2 passengers sustained
serious injuries, 1
and 1 passenger was
fatally injured. Visual
conditions prevailed and
flight plan was filed
for the local flight.
The flight originated
from the Honolulu
The pilot reported that
while in cruise flight
over Ford Island, he
felt a vibration
a grinding noise.
Shortly after, the pilot
heard a loud bang,
scanned the instrument
panel and saw
that the engine
the engine was still
running, however, rotor
The pilot initiated an
autorotation to a grassy
area near Contemplation
Circle at the World War
in the Pacific National
Monument. As the pilot
neared his intended
landing area, he
people within the area.
The pilot stated he
initiated a left pedal
turn, attempting to land
close to the shoreline.
rapidly into the water,
about 20 feet from the
The helicopter was
submerged in about 40
feet of water, about 20
feet from the shoreline.
was removed from the
water the day following
the accident and was
subsequently rinsed with
All major structural
components of the
One person remains
missing in the ditching
of a Piper PA-28 (exact
aircraft into Port
Jefferson Harbor, NY, an
inlet of the
Long Island Sound. Four
people were on board.
Three were rescued from
water and treated at a
local hospital. Initial
that the airplane
had flown from Republic
NY, to Fitchburg, MA,
was returning to
Farmingdale. A student
pilot and his instructor
occupying the front
seats. When the airplane
trouble, the instructor
assumed control and
executed the forced
in the water. That was
at about 11 pm on
Friday, February 20,
Neither the airplane
wreckage nor the fourth
person had been located
as of approximately 10
am Saturday. The NTSB
will join the FAA
in the investigation.
Two bodies have been
recovered from the
wreckage of a
which crashed into water
near Destin, Florida,
shortly before 7 p.m.,
on February 11, 2016.
The airplane was
reported overdue at the
Destin airport. A
witness called 911 and
reported seeing the
airplane go into the
water not far from
Henderson Beach where he
had been running. It was
not immediately known
where the airplane was
where the flight
originated. The NTSB is
FLIGHT DESIGN CTLS
The NTSB is
February 10, 2016, crash
of a Flight Design
CTLS light sport
in which the pilot and
a Tulare County Deputy
Sheriff were killed.
They had been on a
spot a man with a gun
California. The man was
captured by law
enforcement personnel on
the ground. The airplane
a hillside adjacent to a
SAN PEDRO MID-AIR
A Citabria and a Beech
35 Bonanza collided over
the ocean off San Pedo,
on February 5, 2016. the
two men on the B-35 and
the woman on the
presumed to have been
killed. The Coast Guard
suspended its search for
Divers found found
pieces of wreckage and a
logbook belonging to one
occupants of the B-35.
Both airplanes departed
from the Torrance
The NTSB is
February 5, 2016, crash
of a P-51D Mustang
near Maricopa, Arizona,
in which the former
president of Sikorsky
was killed. Jeffrey
Pinto, age 61, was
identified as having
been the pilot of the
airplane. He had been
president of Sikorsky,
based in Stratford,
from 2006 to 2012. The
occupant was identified
The Mustang is a World
Two members of the Civil
Air Patrol in Albama
were killed in the
February 1, 2016, crash
Cessna 182 operated by
the CAP about one mile
west of the Mobile
Regional Airport. The
wreckage was located
about 2 am on February 2
when searchers were able
to track the
signal. The CAP members
had flown a medical
Airport near Baton
Rouge, Louisiana, and
were returning to
The pilot was identified
as Maj. David R.
president of the Flying
He received the FPA's
Award in 2004.
The other crewmember was
Second Lt. Phil J.
Dryden, who was the
Officer for the CAP in
The NTSB is
investigating the crash
of an Echo P-92 light
sport aircraft on
February 1, 2016, at
the Houston Southwest
Airport in Arcola,
Texas. The flight
instructor was killed
and the student
injuries. A post crash
fire erupted. The
airplane impacted next
to a hangar.
CESSNA CITATION 525
The NTSB is
January 18, 2016, crash
of a Cessna Citation 525
near Cedar Fort,
Utah. Both occupants
were killed. The pilot
was identified as Donald
L. Baker, a commercial
estate operator from
Tucson, Arizona, and his
wife. The airplane had
departed Salt Lake City
and was en route to
reportedly told the Utah
County Sheriff's Office
that they heard a loud
noise and saw the
on fire as it descended.
It was reported that
Baker had attended a
conference in Park City,
Utah. The Citation jet
flown single-pilot under
an exemption issued by
the FAA provided the
airplane meets certain
and the pilot meets
certain rating and
On December 11, 2015, at
eastern daylight time, a
was destroyed when it
impacted trees and
terrain after a loss of
control during a return
airport, after takeoff
from Nemacolin Airport
private pilot was
fatally injured. Visual
and no flight plan was
Part 91 personal flight,
destined for Montgomery
County Airport (GAI),
According to witness
departure from runway 23
at PA88, the landing
gear on the airplane was
observed to retract, and
the airplane "made a
sudden turn like it was
trying to turn around."
The landing gear then
extended into the down
position. The airplane
was next observed
turning onto a close in,
left base leg for
runway 23 "pretty low"
to the ground, about 800
yards from the Nemacolin
Woodlands Resort Outdoor
Exhibits Area, and then
was lost from sight as
it passed behind the
Pavilion. Moments later
sound of the airplane
impacting trees and then
the ground was heard,
and a "fireball" and
smoke was observed to
rise into the air.
The airplane came to
rest in a heavily wooded
area located next to the
11th fairway of the
resort's Links Golf
and was subject to a pos
BELL 407 MEDICAL
On December 10, 2015,
about 1908 Pacific
standard time, a Bell
407 was destroyed
when it impacted terrain
during cruise flight
to American Airborne
EMS, Fresno, California,
and operated by Rogers
Helicopters, DBA SkyLife,
under the provisions of
Title 14 Code of Federal
Regulations Part 135.
The Air Medical Flight
was SkyLife 4. The
commercial pilot, flight
paramedic, flight nurse,
and patient sustained
conditions prevailed and
a company visual flight
rules (VFR) flight plan
was filed for the
The cross-country flight
originated from the
at 1851 with an intended
destination of the San
Information provided by
the operator, FAA, and
local law enforcement
revealed that the
facilitate transfer of a
patient to a hospital in
At 1918, a dispatcher
radioed the pilot to
confirm their status;
there was no response.
The dispatcher inquired
hospital, and personnel
at Bakersfield Meadows
Airport and verified the
flight had not reached
Shortly thereafter, law
began a search near the
last known location of
SkyLife 4. The FAA
subsequently issued an
Alert Notification (ALNOT)
at 2034. The wreckage
was later located
by local law enforcement
air units at 2054.
Examination of the
accident site revealed
that the helicopter
impacted open hilly
terrain about 9 miles
McFarland. All major
structural components of
the helicopter were
located within the
wreckage debris path,
that was about 465 feet
in length, and oriented
on a heading of about
037 degrees magnetic.
was recovered to a
secure location for
The NTSB has adopted a
probable cause of the
October 18, 2013,
accident at Derby,
involving a Cessna 500
jet in which the pilot
and passenger were
After climbing to and
leveling at 15,000 feet,
the airplane departed
rapidly in a nose-down
vertical dive, and
impacted terrain; an
explosion and post
accident fire occurred.
Evidence at the accident
site revealed that most
of the wreckage was
located in or near a
single impact crater;
however, the outer
portion of the left wing
impacted the ground
about 1/2 mile from the
Following the previous
flight, the pilot
reported to a
maintenance person in
another state that he
including the autopilot,
the horizontal situation
and the artificial
horizon gyros. The
pilot, who was not a
replace the right side
artificial horizon gyro
but did not have any
performed at that time.
The pilot was approved
an FAA exemption to
operate the airplane as
a single pilot; however,
the exemption required
that all equipment
must be operational,
including a fully
flight director, and
instruments. Despite the
instruments, the pilot
chose to take off and
fly in instrument
At the time of the loss
of control, the airplane
had just entered an area
with supercooled large
severe icing, which
would have affected the
characteristics. At the
same time, the air
provided the pilot with
a radio frequency
change, a change in
assigned altitude, and a
slight routing change.
It is likely that these
the pilot's workload as
the airplane began to
Because of the
instruments, it is
likely that the pilot
became disoriented while
maneuver and maintain
control of the airplane
as the ice accumulated,
which led to a loss of
The NTSB determined
that the probable
cause of this
accident was the
which resulted in
and the pilot's
maneuvering in IFR
led to the
subsequent loss of
Contributing to the
accident was the
pilot's decision to
off in IFR
conditions and fly a
operation without a
autopilot and with
On November 10, 2015, about 1452 eastern standard time (EST), Execuflight flight 1526,
a British Aerospace HS 125-700A, N237WR, departed controlled flight while on approach
to landing at Akron Fulton International Airport (AKR) and impacted a 4-plex apartment
building in Akron, Ohio. The pilot, copilot, and seven passengers died; no ground injuries
were reported. The airplane was destroyed by the crash and a postcrash fire. The airplane
was registered to Rais Group International NC LLC and operated by Execuflight under the
provisions of 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 135 as an on-demand charter flight.
Instrument meteorological conditions prevailed, and an instrument flight rules flight
plan was filed. The flight departed from Dayton-Wright Brothers Airport (MGY), Dayton, Ohio,
about 1413 EST and was destined for AKR.
The airplane, which was based at Fort Lauderdale Executive Airport, Fort Lauderdale, Florida,
departed Cincinnati Municipal Airport-Lunken Field, Cincinnati, Ohio, about 1112 EST on the day
of the accident and arrived at MGY about 1125 EST. The airplane remained parked on the ramp
at one of the fixed-base operators until departing for AKR.
According to Federal Aviation Administration air traffic control and radar data, about 1438 EST,
the Akron-Canton terminal radar approach control facility provided radar vectors to the
accident airplane for the localizer runway 25 instrument approach procedure at AKR.
A Piper PA-28-161 airplane performing flight training at the airport completed the localizer
runway 25 instrument approach procedure at AKR before the accident airplane began its approach.
According to the flight instructor on board the Piper PA-28-161, the airplane "broke out at
minimums" on the localizer runway 25 approach and landed on runway 25. After the Piper PA-28-161
exited the runway, the flight instructor reported that he heard one of the pilots of the accident
airplane state "Hawker Jet on a 10 mile final localizer 25" over the Unicom frequency. S
ubsequently, the flight instructor radioed to the accident airplane and stated "we broke out
right at minimums." According to the flight instructor, one of the pilots of the accident airplane
acknowledged this transmission with "thanks for the update."
About 1452 EST, a motion-activated security camera located about 900 ft to the southeast
of the accident site captured the airplane as it came in over the surrounding trees in
a left-wing-down attitude about 1.8 nautical miles from the approach end of runway 25 at AKR.
An explosion and postcrash fire were observed on the video just after the airplane flew out of
the security camera's view.
The postcrash fire consumed most of the airplane; however, the airframe, engines, primary flight
controls, and landing gear were all accounted for at the accident site. The airplane was equipped
with a Fairchild GA-100 tape unit cockpit voice recorder, which was recovered and sent to the
National Transportation Safety Board's Vehicle Recorders Laboratory for examination.
About 1450 EST, the surface weather observation at AKR was wind from 240 degrees at 7 knots;
visibility 1 3/4 statute mile in mist; ceiling broken at 600 ft above ground level (agl); overcast
ceiling at 900 ft agl; temperature 11 degrees C (52 degrees F); dew point 9 degrees C
(48 degrees F); and altimeter 29.95 inches of mercury.
The NTSB continues to investigate the October 29, 2015, fire on a Boeing 767
being operated as Dynamic International Airways flight 405. The airplane was
taxiing prior to takeoff at Fort Lauderdale–Hollywood International Airport (FLL),
Ft. Lauderdale, Florida,
• The NTSB found that the main fuel supply line coupling assembly had disconnected
in the wing-to-engine strut above and behind the left engine. This coupling assembly
has been retained for further examination.
• Examination of the left engine revealed no evidence of an engine uncontained or
• The lower inboard portion of the left wing, left engine cowling, and left fuselage center
section sustained thermal damage. The fire did not penetrate the fuselage.
• The FDR/CVR were transported to the NTSB Recorders Laboratory in Washington, DC,
and are being downloaded and evaluated.
• The NTSB is reviewing the airplane maintenance records at Dynamic International Airways’
headquarters in North Carolina. According to the aircraft records, the accident airplane was in
dry storage for approximately 29 months until September 2015 when Dynamic International
Airways leased the airplane. Dynamic International Airways has operated the airplane for about
240 hours under the present lease.
• An initial review of the airplane onboard logbook revealed there was no entry of maintenance
action having been performed in the area of the fuel coupling prior to the accident flight while in FLL.
• NTSB investigators have interviewed the two flight crew members and nine cabin crew members.
• Of the 90 passengers and 11 crewmembers onboard the airplane, one was seriously injured and
21 sustained minor injuries as a result of the emergency evacuation.
• Dynamic International Airways has issued a Fleet Campaign Directive to inspect the remainder
of their aircraft to ensure proper installation of the fuel line coupling assemblies.
DHC-3 WITH 10 FATALITIES
The National Transportation Safety Board found that the probable cause for the crash of a
deHavilland DHC-3 in Soldotna, Alaska, on July 7, 2013, was the operator’s failure to
determine the actual cargo weight, leading to the loading and operation of the airplane
outside of its weight and center of gravity limits.
Contributing to the accident was the Federal Aviation Administration’s failure to
require weight and balance documentation for this type of air taxi flight.
The flight was headed from Soldotna to a lodge 90 miles away when the airplane stalled
and crashed on takeoff. The airplane was destroyed by impact forces and post-crash fire
and the pilot and nine passengers were fatally injured.
A video of the airplane’s taxi, takeoff roll and takeoff was recovered from a passenger’s
personal electronic device. An NTSB video study indicated that shortly after takeoff,
the airplane’s angle of attack continually increased as the airplane’s airspeed decreased
from about 68 mph to about 44 mph over a period of about 8.5 seconds. About 11 seconds
after takeoff, airspeed and angle of attack reached values consistent with an aerodynamic stall.
The airplane rolled right-wing-down and impacted the ground several seconds later.
The weight of the cargo recovered from the crash site, and determination of the weight of cargo
destroyed in the impact and post-crash fire, showed the cargo weight was about 418 pounds higher
than the cargo weight stated on the load manifest, resulting in a center of gravity aft of the
limits for the airplane.
BEECH G35 - South Lake
On October 10, 2015
about 1735 Pacific
daylight time, a Beech
G35, N4485D, was
destroyed when it
impacted terrain while
maneuvering near South
Lake Tahoe, California.
The pilot, who was the
registered owner of the
airplane, and the
fatal injuries. The
flight was conducted
under the provisions of
14 Code of Federal
Regulations (CFR) Part
91 as a personal
prevailed at the time of
the accident, and no
flight plan had been
filed. The flight
originated from Lake
Tahoe Airport (TVL),
South Lake Tahoe, about
reported that shortly
after takeoff from
runway 18, the airplane
sounded as it was not
power. One witness
downdrafts in the area.
As it exited the airport
boundaries on the runway
heading, the airplane
made a right turn
followed by a left turn.
It climbed to about 100
feet above ground level
(agl) in an excessively
high pitch up attitude,
and continued to fly
towards the rising
thereafter, after it
crossed the ridgeline,
the airplane entered a
nose and left-wing low
attitude and impacted
the back yard of a
residence. A post crash
On October 8, 2015, at
0826 Pacific daylight
time, a Cessna 182P
airplane collided with
about 3.5 miles
northeast of Hope,
Idaho. The private pilot
and the commercial pilot
were fatally injured,
passenger has not been
located and is presumed
to be a fatality. The
airplane impacted large
pine trees near a
mountain ridge line and
was destroyed by a
post-crash fire. The
airplane was registered
to the private pilot,
and operated under Part
91 as a personal flight.
conditions prevailed for
the flight, and a flight
plan had not been filed.
The flight originated at
the Bird Nr 2 air strip,
Sagle, Idaho, at 0816,
and was destined for
Minot, North Dakota.
The Bonner County
Sheriff reported that at
0826 he received reports
of a single emergency
locator transmitter ping
in the vicinity
northeast of Hope. About
6 hours later a
helicopter located the
wreckage just below a
ridgeline saddle in the
mountains above Hope, at
an elevation of 5,226
feet MSL. The airplane
had first impacted
numerous tree tops then
collided with terrain
about 156 feet later,
along a 046-degree
magnetic bearing line.
There was a post-crash
fire that destroyed the
airplane cabin. Both
pilots were located in
the wreckage, however,
the passenger, who had
been in the rear seats
of the airplane, has not
Family members reported
that the intended route
of flight was to depart
Sagle, proceed to Minot,
then over to Maine, and
then proceed along the
east coast of the US,
with a final destination
of Gainesville, Florida.
The flight had been
planned to depart on
Wednesday, October 7,
but was delayed due to
poor weather conditions.
Just before the airplane
departed the pilot-rated
passenger told the ranch
foreman that they were
heading to Minot, but
because of the weather
they were probably going
to try to go south. The
ranch foreman also
stated that on Tuesday
he had fueled the
airplane to maximum
The NTSB sent
investigators to Japan
to look into the October
2, 2015, incident
involving Delta Air
Lines flight 158, a
Boeing 747-451 en route
from Seoul, Korea to
Detroit, Michigan while
operating in Russian air
space, had an in-flight
shutdown of the No. 3
engine, a Pratt &
Whitney PW4056. The
airplane diverted to
Airport, Tokyo, Japan
for landing. When
were removing the engine
from the airplane, it
was noted that there
were several holes in
the low pressure turbine
case. There were nicks
to the right wing's flap
and aileron and the
leading edge of the
from the No. 3 engine's
PIPER SARATOGA UPDATE
On October 2, 2015,
about 1512 eastern
daylight time, a Piper
PA-32R-301 collided with
terrain following an
in-flight breakup near
Carolina. The private
pilot and three
passengers were fatally
occupants were planning
to attend a football
game on October 3
between Clemson and
The airplane was
destroyed by impact
forces. The airplane was
registered to Smith
Family Aviation LLC and
operated by the pilot
under Part 91 as a
personal flight. Day,
conditions prevailed at
the time of the
accident, and an
instrument flight rules
(IFR) flight plan was
filed. The flight
originated from Warsaw
Municipal Airport (ASW),
Warsaw, Indiana and was
destined for Oconee
County Regional Airport
(CEU), Clemson, South
According to preliminary
information provided by
the FAA, the airplane
was at 6,000 feet MSL,
intersection to hold for
the RNAV runway 7
approach at CEU. The
pilot was subsequently
cleared for the approach
and reported that the
airplane was established
outbound on the
procedure turn. The
queried the pilot when
he did not report
inbound on the approach;
no response was
received. Radar contact
was lost over Lake
Hartwell, on the
border, about 2,200 feet
Local residents reported
hearing and seeing the
airplane prior to the
accident. One witness
heard a loud "boom,"
followed by white pieces
of debris falling into
the lake. Another
witness saw the airplane
in a spiral motion,
until it disappeared
behind a tree line.
Another witness reported
that the engine was
running until ground
witnesses reported the
event to 911, and the
wreckage was located by
first responders shortly
The pilot, age 71, held
a private pilot
airplane single engine
land and instrument
airplane ratings. He
reported 1,448 hours
total flight time on his
most recent application
for an FAA third-class
dated October 17, 2013.
The main wreckage was
found inverted in a
wooded area, about 50
yards north of the
shoreline of Lake
Westminster. Damage to
trees was indicative of
a near-vertical descent
angle at impact. There
was no fire. The main
wreckage consisted of
the main cabin, cockpit,
engine, propeller, left
wing, and the inboard
half of the right wing.
About 10 percent of the
empennage was recovered
near the south shoreline
the lake, near Toccoa,
Witnesses have told
investigators that white
smoke was coming from
the underside of the
Beech S35 before it
at Pagosa Springs,
Colorado, on September
25, 2015. The S35
following a loss of
engine power while
maneuvering. The private
pilot and passenger
injuries. The airplane
was destroyed by impact
and post accident fire.
The airplane was
registered to and
operated by a private
individual as a 14 Code
of Federal Regulations
Part 91 personal flight.
conditions prevailed at
the time of the
accident, and no flight
plan was filed, nor was
one required. The
airplane departed the
Durango-La Plata County
Airport (DRO), Durango,
Colorado, at an unknown
The airplane departed
DRO with another
airplane en route to
Stevens Field Airport (PSO),
Pagosa Springs, and the
two pilots planned to
participate in an air
race competition in the
Pagosa Springs area on
September 26th. Prior to
landing at PSO, the
pilots in the two
airplanes decided to
execute a circuit in the
Pagosa Springs air race
course. As the airplanes
entered the course, the
accident airplane was
behind the other
airplane. After the
first course waypoint,
the accident pilot
radioed the other pilot
and stated the engine
lost power, and the
airplane was going down.
heard from the accident
Witnesses, who were
located in the Pagosa
Springs area, reported
observing white smoke
coming from the
underside of the
accident airplane. The
airplane turned left,
descended below rising
terrain, and a smoke
plume was then seen
Witnesses stated the sky
was clear and the winds
The NTSB is
September 15, 2015,
crash of a float
DHC-3T turboprop at a
lake in the Southwest
Alaska town of Iliamna.
Three of the ten people
on board were killed.
The plane was taking
guests of a fishing
lodge to a fishing site.
NTSB investigator Clint
Johnson said the
airplane was owned and
operated by Rainbow King
Lodge. It crashed on
takeoff from East Wind
Lake. Johnson said the
passengers consisted of
lodge guests and fishing
guides. The accident was
first reported to Alaska
State Troopers at about
The NTSB is investigating the September 8, 2015, engine fire that occurred during takeoff
of British Airways flight 2276, a Boeing 777-200ER, at McCarran International Airport (LAS), in
Las Vegas, NV. NTSB investigators arrived on scene Wednesday morning local time to begin
the on-scene investigation. The NTSB investigative team includes experts in powerplants,
airplane systems, and fire.
The initial factual findings follow.
The Part 129 flight was en route to London - Gatwick Airport (LGW), Horley, England.
There were 157 passengers, including 1 lap child, and 13 crewmembers on board.
There were several minor injuries as a result of the evacuation (mostly abrasions).
The flight data recorder, cockpit voice recorder and quick access recorder have arrived at the
NTSB Vehicle Recorder Laboratory and are currently being downloaded.
On Tuesday evening, the airplane was photographed and the runway debris documented by FAA
and airport officials before airplane was towed to secluded area of the airport (in order to reopen the runway).
Initial examination of the left engine revealed multiple breaches of the engine case in the area
around the high pressure compressor.
Examination of the material recovered from runway found several pieces of the high pressure
compressor spool (approximately 7-8 inches in length).
Initial examination of the airplane by NTSB revealed that the left engine and pylon, left fuselage
structure and inboard left wing airplane were substantially damaged by the fire.
The NTSB says the
probable cause of the
May 31, 2014, crash of a
Gulfstream G-IV business
jet at Hanscom Field
in Bedford, MA, was a
series of errors by an
experienced flight crew.
The NTSB determined that
the pilots failed to
perform a flight control
check before takeoff,
then attempted to take
off while critical
flight controls were
locked because a gust
lock was engaged.
Finally, they delayed
rejecting the take-off
after they became aware
the flight controls were
At 9:40 pm EDT, the
G-IV, bound for Atlantic
City, NJ, overran the
end of runway 11 during
a rejected takeoff at
Laurence G. Hanscom
Field. The airplane
rolled through the paved
overrun area; continued
across a grassy area,
striking approach lights
and an antenna; and
traveled through the
airport fence before
coming to rest in a
ravine. A post crash
fire engulfed the
aboard – two pilots, a
flight attendant and
four passengers – were
During the engine start
process, the flight crew
failed to disengage the
airplane’s gust lock
system, which locks the
primary flight control
surfaces while the plane
is parked to protect
them against wind gusts.
The flight data recorder
and cockpit voice
recorder indicated that
neither of the two
flight crewmembers, who
had flown together for
about 12 years, had
performed a basic flight
control check that would
have alerted them to the
locked flight controls.
A review of the flight
crew’s previous 175
flights revealed that
the pilots had performed
control checks on only
two of them. The flight
checklists was a
contributing factor to
About 26 seconds into
the takeoff roll, when
the airplane had reached
a speed of 148 mph (129
kts), the pilot in
command indicated that
the flight controls were
locked, but the crew did
not begin to apply the
brakes for another 10
seconds and did not
reduce engine power
until four more seconds
had passed. The NTSB
determined that if the
crew had rejected the
takeoff within 11
seconds of the pilot’s
comment, the airplane
would have stopped on
the paved surface and
the accident would have
The G-IV gust lock
system design was
intended to limit the
operation of the
throttles when the
system was engaged so
that the flight crew
would have an
that the gust lock was
on should the crew
attempt to take off.
that Gulfstream did not
ensure that the gust
lock system would
sufficiently limit the
throttle movement on the
G-IV airplane, which
allowed the pilots of
the accident flight to
accelerate the airplane
to takeoff speed before
they discovered that the
flight controls were
The NTSB said that the
FAA’s certification of
the gust lock system was
inadequate because it
did not require
Gulfstream to perform
certification tests or
analysis of the G-IV
gust lock system to
verify that the system
had met its regulatory
Also contributing to the
Gulfstream’s failure to
ensure that the gust
lock system would
prevent an attempted
takeoff with the gust
lock engaged and the
FAA’s failure to detect
this inadequacy during
As a result of the
investigation, the NTSB
issued a total of five
to the FAA, the
Aviation Council and the
In addition, the NTSB
developed a Safety Alert
for all pilots on the
importance of following
procedures and using
checklists to guard
The pilot of a
Bonanza which crashed on
Long Island Rail Road
tracks at Hicksville,
NY, on August 16, 2015,
was trying to find an
abandoned runway at the
closed Grumman Bethpage
Airport for an emergency
landing, according to
Board. The pilot was
killed and his passenger
The Part 135 air taxi
flight originated from
Westhampton Beach on
Long Island and was en
route to Morristown, New
According to radar data
and voice communications
provided by the FAA, the
airplane was at 6,500
feet mean sea level
about 8 nautical miles
northwest of Republic
Airport in Farmingdale
when the pilot radioed a
controller that he was
"having a little bit of
a problem" and may need
to land at Farmingdale.
The pilot then reported
that he would have to
"take it down…" The
controller provided the
relative locations of
LaGuardia, JFK and
The pilot responded that
Farmingdale was closest.
The pilot then indicated
that he may not make
controller then provided
information on the
closed Grumman Bethpage
Airport at Bethpage,
saying there was a
runway there. The pilot
radioed that he could
not see the runway, and
the controller continued
to provide heading and
until the airplane was
lost from radar. The
accident site was
northwest of a former
runway's approach end.
At one time, the airport
had two paved runways,
but very little remains
today. The former
airport has been
developed with new
industrial buildings, in
addition to the ones
remaining from the
The passenger told
during cruise flight he
heard a loud "pop"
sound, followed by an
"oil smell." The engine
then began to "sputter"
and lose power. The
pilot tried, but failed
to restart the engine.
The pilot, age 59, was
Joseph Milo. He held a
ratings. He reported
3,300 hours total flight
time on his most recent
application for an FAA
December 22, 2014.
Records provided by the
FAA revealed that he
completed a Part 135.299
line check (check ride)
on June 18, 2015.
The main wreckage was
found inverted and
burned on the railroad
tracks for the Long
Island Rail Road. The
wreckage debris field
was about 100 feet in
length and about 20 feet
wide. All major
structural components of
the aircraft were found
within the confines of
the debris field. The
right wing was found
under the grade crossing
cantilever arm, which
separated from its mount
structure during the
initial impact. The
engine was retained for
LOSS OF CONTROL ACCIDENTS
The NTSB will hold a one-day forum, free and open to the public, to examine the problem of loss-of-control crashes
in general aviation, and explore possible solutions. The event, “Humans and Hardware: Preventing Inflight Loss
of Control in General Aviation,” is scheduled to be held from 9 am – 5 pm ET on October 14, 2015, in Washington, D.C.
Topics addressed will include an overview of the types of loss of control accidents, human performance and
medical issues, potential training improvements, and technological enhancements that can reduce loss of
control accidents. The forum will feature presentations from pilots, instructors, general aviation advocacy
groups, the Federal Aviation Administration, and manufacturers of potential technological countermeasures,
The NTSB has opened an
Saturday’s accident that
occurred when a
damage following a tail
strike during an
On August 15, 2015, at
about 6:34 pm eastern
daylight time, an Airbus
A321, operated by
American Airlines as
Flight 1851 inbound from
encountered wind shear
on final approach to the
The airplane impacted
runway approach lights
followed by an airplane
tail to runway impact.
The flight crew then
performed a go-around
maneuver and completed
the landing. No injuries
were reported; however,
the airplane was
The flight data recorder
and cockpit voice
recorder have been
brought to the NTSB
Laboratory in Washington
where they are being
downloaded and analyzed.
TUSKEGEE AIRMAN AIRCRAFT
The NTSB is
investigating the August
9, 2015, crash of a
registered to the
Tuskegee Airmen National
Historical Museum. The
airplane crashed while
on a night approach to
the Harbor Springs
Airport, Harbor Springs,
MI. The pilot was
killed. He was
identified as Arthur
Green, age 58, a Vice
President of the
Tuskegee Airmen National
Historical Museum. He
was the only person on
board. He worked for the
Michigan Department of
Natural Resources and
was going to Harbor
Springs for a department
The main wreckage of the
airplane was located in
sloping and forested
terrain. The nose of the
airplane was oriented to
the east and the main
wreckage of the airplane
included the fuselage,
empennage, and engine
and propeller assembly.
The right wing separated
and came to rest
immediately adjacent and
to the north of the main
wreckage. The left wing
separated and came to
rest uphill and to the
south of the main
statistics for 2014 on
August 6 showing a
slight increase in fatal
increased from 222 in
2013 to 253 in 2014.
overall number of
slightly from 1,224 in
2013 to 1,221 in 2014.
Despite reporting fewer
accidents, the accident
rate for general
increased from 6.26 per
100,000 flight hours in
the previous year to
6.74 in 2014.
were 28 accidents
involving Part 121
number of accidents
involving scheduled Part
from seven in 2013 to
four in 2014.
Part 135 operations,
which include charter,
air taxi, air tour, and
air medical flights,
reported 35 accidents in
2014, down from 44 in
2013. The accident rate
decreased from 1.30 per
100,000 flight hours in
2013 to 1.02 in 2014.
HELICOPTER FUEL SYSTEMS
The NTSB has called on
the FAA to order that
all newly manufactured
crashworthy fuel systems
to help prevent fuel-fed
fires in accidents. In
1994, the FAA imposed
construction specs were
approved before the
went into effect can
still be built without
having a crashworthy
fuel system. The NTSB
says as of November
2014, the FAA aircraft
registry includes more
than 5,600 helicopters
manufactured since 1994.
However, of those,
provided by the FAA,
only about 850 (or 15%)
are models with
systems that meet the
HARRISON FORD ACCIDENT
The NTSB has released
some details of its
investigation into the
March 5, 2015, accident
in which actor Harrison
Ford was seriously
injured. Ford's 1942
Ryan Aeronautical ST3KR
damage during a forced
landing following a
reported loss of engine
power shortly after
takeoff and during
initial climb-out from
the Santa Monica
Municipal Airport (SMO),
conditions prevailed for
the personal flight.
finding a discrepancy
with the main fuel
metering jet which
provides a constant
air/fuel mixture for the
engine to burn. However,
a probable cause for the
accident has not been
During an interview with
Ford reported that,
shortly after takeoff
and about 1,100 feet
mean sea level, the
engine experienced a
loss of power. He stated
that he did not attempt
an engine restart but
maintained an airspeed
of 85 mph and initiated
a left turn back toward
the airport; however,
during the approach, he
realized that the
airplane was unable to
reach the runway. Ford
did not recall anything
further about the
airplane struck the top
of a tree that was about
65 feet tall, and then
impacted the ground in
an open area of a golf
course. Fuel was
observed leaking from
the front of the
airplane, and the
shutting off the
airplane's fuel supply
from the cockpit.
The main metering jet
was found unscrewed from
its seat and rotated
laterally about 90
degrees. The internal
cap, main metering jet,
and seat appeared to be
bright in color and
polished. Portions of
the jet threads appeared
to be rounded off. No
gasket was observed
within the main metering
jet housing. In
addition, no evidence of
thread locking compound
was observed on the
threads of the main
metering jet or the
threads of the seat.
According to the 1943
Manual for Models 419
and 429, the actual
metering of the fuel is
accomplished by the main
metering jet located in
the passage between the
discharge nozzle and the
A review of the
revealed that an
extensive restoration of
the airplane and engine
overhaul was completed
on May 21, 1998. At the
time of the accident,
the airframe and engine
approximately 169 hours
since the restoration.
An entry stated that a
new float and gasket
were installed in the
carburetor during this
time. The airplane was
issued a standard-normal
certificate on June 4,
1998. Review of the
Manual for Models 419
and 429, revealed that
there were no pertinent
the installation or
continued maintenance of
the jet assemblies.
Further, no maintenance
entries were located in
the engine logbook
inspections since the
The NTSB has determined the probable cause of the October 4, 2014, crash of a Bell 206L1+ medical helicopter at about 0155 central daylight time while on approach to the United Regional Hospital helipad, in Wichita Falls, Texas. The commercial pilot was seriously injured and the flight nurse, paramedic, and patient died.
The pilot reported that he was making an approach to a hospital helipad into light wind at night when he chose to go around because he fe...lt that the approach was too high and fast. The pilot lowered the helicopter’s nose, added power, and raised the collective control, and the helicopter then entered a rapid, “violent” right spin. The helicopter was under its maximum allowable gross weight at the time of the accident, and the wind was less than 4 knots. The NTSB investigation determined that it is likely the pilot did not adequately account for the helicopter’s low airspeed when he applied power to go around, which resulted in a sudden, uncommanded right yaw due to a loss of tail rotor effectiveness.
On July 11, 2015 about
1600 Pacific daylight
time, a Beechcraft A35,
N8749A, was destroyed
when it impacted terrain
while maneuvering near
Mazama, Washington. The
pilot and one passenger
were fatally injured.
The second passenger
injuries. The airplane
was registered to, and
operated by, the pilot
as a 14 Code of Federal
Regulations (CFR) Part
91 personal flight.
conditions prevailed for
flight, which operated
on a visual rules flight
conditions were reported
near the accident site.
The flight originated
from Red Eagle Aviation
Montana, at about 1415
mountain standard time,
with an intended
destination of Lynden
On July 11, 2015, an
Alert Notification (ALNOT)
was issued for the
accident aircraft. On
July 13, 2015, a
survivor was located on
Highway 20 near Easy
Pass Head Trail, Skagit
County, Washington. In a
provided to Okanogan
Department, she reported
that she was flying home
from Montana with her
airplane flew into
clouds and the pilot was
using a GPS to navigate
with. When the airplane
exited the clouds, she
could see the mountain
in front of the
airplane. In an attempt
to gain the altitude,
the pilot pulled back on
the yoke but he was
terrain, and a
ensued. The survivor
attempted to extract the
pilot and the other
passenger from the
wreckage, but was
F-16 / CESSNA MIDAIR
The NTSB has gathered information about the July 7, 2015, midair collision of a military fighter and a civilian airplane. It appears that the military pilot was aware of the civilian airplane's presence, and the controller handling the military jet gave the pilot instructions to avoid it.
At 1100 eastern daylight time, a Cessna 150M, N3601V, and a Lockheed-Martin F-16CM, operated by the U.S. Air Force (USAF), collided in midair near Moncks Corner, South Carolina. The Cessna was destroyed during the collision, and both the private pilot and passenger were fatally injured. The damaged F-16 continued to fly for an additional 3 minutes until the pilot activated the airplane's ejection system. The F-16 was destroyed following the subsequent collision with terrain and post-impact fire, while the pilot landed safely and was uninjured. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed, and no flight plan was filed for the Cessna, while the F-16 was operating on an instrument flight rules flight plan. The Cessna departed from Berkley County Airport (MKS), Moncks Corner, South Carolina, at 1057, and was destined for Grand Strand Airport (CRE), North Myrtle Beach, South Carolina; the personal flight was conducted under the provisions of Title 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91. The F-16 had departed from Shaw Air Force Base (SSC), Sumter, South Carolina about 1020.
According to the USAF, after departing from SSC, the F-16 proceeded to Myrtle Beach International Airport (MYR), Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, where the pilot conducted two practice instrument approaches before continuing the flight to Charleston Air Force Base/International Airport (CHS), Charleston, South Carolina. According to preliminary air traffic control (ATC) radar and voice communication data provided by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), the F-16 pilot contacted the approach controller at CHS about 1052 and requested to perform a practice tactical air navigation system (TACAN) instrument approach to runway 15. The controller subsequently instructed the F-16 pilot to fly a heading of 260 degrees to intercept the final approach course. At 1055, the controller instructed the F-16 pilot to descend from his present altitude of 6,000 feet to 1,600 feet. About that time, the F-16 was located about 34 nautical miles northeast of CHS.
At 1057:41, a radar target displaying a visual flight rules transponder code of 1200, and later correlated to be the accident Cessna, appeared in the vicinity of the departure end of runway 23 at MKS, at an indicated altitude of 200 feet. The Cessna continued its climb, and began tracking generally southeast over the next 3 minutes. For the duration of its flight, the pilot of the Cessna did not contact CHS approach control, nor was he required to do so. At 1100:18, the controller advised the pilot of the F-16, "traffic 12 o'clock, 2 miles, opposite direction, 1,200 [feet altitude] indicated, type unknown." The F-16 pilot responded and advised the controller that he was "looking" for the traffic. At 1100:26, the controller advised the F-16 pilot, "turn left heading 180 if you don't have that traffic in sight." The pilot responded by asking, "confirm 2 miles?" Eight seconds later, the controller stated, "if you don't have that traffic in sight turn left heading 180 immediately." Over the next 18 seconds, the track of the F-16 began turning southerly.
At 1100:49, the radar target of the F-16 was located 1/2 nautical mile northeast of the Cessna, at an indicated altitude of 1,500 feet, and was on an approximate track of 215 degrees. At that time, the Cessna reported an indicated altitude of 1,400 feet, and was established on an approximate track of 110 degrees. At 1100:52 the controller advised the F-16 pilot, "traffic passing below you 1,400 feet." At 1100:54, the radar reported altitude of the F-16 remained at 1,500 feet and no valid altitude information was returned for the radar target associated with the Cessna. At that point the targets were laterally separated by about 1,000 feet. No further radar targets were received from the Cessna, and the next radar target for the F-16 was not received until 1101:13. At 1101:19, the F-16 pilot transmitted a distress call, and no subsequent transmissions were received. Air traffic control radar continued to track the F-16 as it proceeded on a roughly southerly track, and after descending to an indicated altitude of 300 feet, radar contact was lost at 1103:17 in the vicinity of the F-16 crash site.
MID-AIR AVOIDED AT NEWARK
The NTSB says an FAA controller was responsible for an incident involving two airliners at Newark International Airport in New Jersey. The Safety Board has finished its investigation of the April 24, 2014, incident at Newark in which a Boeing 737 and an Embraer ERJ145 regional jet had a near mid-air collision. The Embraer ERJ145 was departing from runway 4R and the Boeing 737-800 arriving to land on runway 29. Neither aircraft sustained damage, and no passengers or crewmembers were injured.
ExpressJet flight 4100 (ASQ4100) was departing on runway 4R for Memphis, Tennessee. United Airlines flight 1243 (UAL1243), a Boeing 737-800, was arriving from San Francisco
The Boeing 737 pilot contacted the Newark control tower while on the visual approach to runway 29. The local controller instructed the pilot to follow a Boeing 717 ahead and then cleared the pilot to land on runway 29. When the Boeing 717 was on short final, the local controller instructed the Embraer pilot to line up and wait on runway 4R. After the Boeing 717 crossed runway 4R, the local controller cleared the Embraer for takeoff. At that time, the Boeing 737 was about 3 miles from the runway 29 threshold; however, the Embraer did not actually begin its takeoff roll until the Boeing 737 was about 1 mile from the runway 29 threshold at 200 feet above the ground. The local controller recognized that the spacing between the Boeing 737 and the Embraer was insufficient and instructed the Boeing 737 pilot to go around. The Embraer continued its takeoff. The controller then provided traffic advisories to both the Boeing 737 and Embraer pilots and instructed the Embraer pilot to maintain visual separation from the Boeing 737. The Boeing 737 subsequently overflew the Embraer at the intersection of runways 29 and 4R. According to recorded Federal Aviation Administration radar data, the closest lateral and vertical proximity between the airplanes was about 160 feet and 400 feet, respectively, which is less than the minimum separation requirements for aircraft operating on intersecting runways.
The NTSB blamed the incident on the local controller’s failure to comply with Federal Aviation Administration separation requirements for aircraft operating on intersecting runways.